Zoning

Pine Island CPO removal

Summary not yet generated for this topic.

Community sentiment

Supportive (1)Opposed (8)

At a glance

Public comments
9
Last 30 days
9

Discussed at 1 meeting in the last 60 days; most recently Nov 2, 2026.

Public comments (9)

OpposedWalter MackNov 2, 2026

A lifelong St. Helena resident warned that removing the CPO would disturb wetlands, invite invasive species and hurricane flooding, and harm the whole island's ecosystem.

Natural Resources Committee - Nov 2, 2026 · 2:31 →
OpposedTim JoyNov 2, 2026

Asked the committee to consider what system would remain to manage change on St. Helena if the CPO is carved up, warning of broad cultural and environmental effects.

Natural Resources Committee - Nov 2, 2026 · 6:16 →
OpposedCarrie MajorNov 2, 2026

A St. Helena resident who asked the committee to follow the staff's denial recommendation and the Planning Commission's 7-0 vote, and to send a clear recommendation of denial to Council.

Natural Resources Committee - Nov 2, 2026 · 9:04 →
OpposedPaula GlennNov 2, 2026

Said the public has spoken in support of the CPO across many meetings and opposed carving out 500 acres for a golf course serving people who don't live on the island.

Natural Resources Committee - Nov 2, 2026 · 9:01 →
OpposedBelinda JonesNov 2, 2026

A St. Helena farmer and educator who described how development of this scale would harm wetlands, wildlife habitat, and water quality, asking the committee to deny the removal.

Natural Resources Committee - Nov 2, 2026 · 13:36 →
OpposedArnold BrownNov 2, 2026

Listed roughly 21 reasons for denial, including spot zoning concerns, overwhelming community support, and calling the developer's offer a 'pay-to-play' scheme.

Natural Resources Committee - Nov 2, 2026 · 16:54 →
OpposedRobert AdamsNov 2, 2026

Penn Center's executive director traced the CPO's roots to the 1990s preservation movement and called it a smart, democratically supported policy that should be maintained.

Natural Resources Committee - Nov 2, 2026 · 20:12 →
OpposedLaMackaNov 2, 2026

Asked the committee to uphold the 2040 Comprehensive Plan and protect the county's natural resources for future generations.

Natural Resources Committee - Nov 2, 2026 · 21:31 →
SupportiveUnidentified ResidentNov 2, 2026

The one pro-development speaker questioned how 150 homes with septic tanks and 90 docks 'conserve the land' better than the golf course plan, and argued both sides haven't been heard fairly.

Natural Resources Committee - Nov 2, 2026 · 23:33 →